St. D of the E sends me things to provoke blog posts, I'm sure of it. And I'll take the bait, especially on this particular issue.
I grew up watching, and loving, Sesame Street. We had a dog named Muppet. Kermit was probably my favorite, although I had a pretty high opinion of Grover, Snuffy, and Big Bird. Who doesn't love "Rubber Duckie" and "Rainbow Connection"? And remember the misadventures of Super Grover? Born in 1980, I consider myself one of the first of America's (and the world's) children to grow up singing that lovable theme song, learning about spelling and phonetics from those lovable puppets, counting with the Count, and watching Cookie Monster overeat. I think we all remember when Mr. Hooper died, and how the show so skillfully and respectfully handled a difficult topic on a show aimed at kids who are just beginning to wonder where babies come from, let alone how life might end. I remember when Harry Belafonte sang "Day-O" with Grover, and with the help of Google, I found an impressive
list of the show's guests.
I could go on and on about the brilliance of Sesame Street. My mom and I used to watch together, and part of what made it so great was that it wasn't saccharine like Barney or countless other modern kid shows. It had humor that both of us could appreciate. And in talking with friends, we all have our favorite skits and characters. We still remember Telly and the Yup Yups, and who doesn't remember that great opening to the theme song, with the parallel ascending thirds....
I don't think that any of us cared that Bert and Ernie were roommates, or gave a second thought to if they were gay. But we do remember when Bert sold his paperclip collection to buy Ernie a soapdish for Rubber Duckie, all the meanwhile Ernie sold Rubber Duckie to buy a cigar box for Bert's paperclip collection. So both Bert and Ernie gave up the thing that they loved most in acts of selfishness to buy a present for the other. I see now that it is a clever and poignant take off on the O'Henry story "The Gift of the Magi," but I didn't know that then. I just remember learning about what it was to be a good and selfless friend. Are Bert and Ernie gay? I guess my response to that is: Does it matter? Perhaps Bert and Ernie should consider a move to Connecticut, where they can now get
partner benefits. At least then they would be able to sleep in the same room.
"C is for Cookie," as far as I was concerned, was a song to teach me that, well,
Cookie Cookie Cookie starts with C. Duh. I didn't think that it was a subliminal Mrs. Field's Cookie ad. I knew that I had to ask my mom for snacks, and that it was far more likely that I'd get carrots and celery than a big pile of Oreos. But, damn, I can still spell cookie. Apparently, now, Cookie Monster will be eating more vegetables and learning about moderation. For some reason, "Carrot Carrot Carrot starts with 'C'" just doesn't have the same ring....
Oscar was a grouch. And that was ok. I certainly have met my share of grouches in my time. And perhaps I learned how to deal with them at a young age by watching the other members of the Sesame Street community deal with Oscar. I have never thought for a minute that Oscar was depressed and/or homeless. I always just assumed that he LIKED living in a garbage can. I also always figured that his garbage can was just like his front door. I mean, he was up on all of those boxes and stuff. I see no reason why his living room didn't extend down. At any rate, it never occured to me until about three minutes ago that Oscar was homeless, or in need of medication. But according to
this article from the Swift Report,
"Our hope is that with a little help, Oscar can gain some self respect, get a job and begin saving some money. Then it's only a matter of time before he's able to join the investor class," says Elmo. "Why should Oscar be denied the entrepreneurial opportunities the rest of us have just because he's spent the past two decades living in a garbage can?"
I think its too bad that Oscar has to move out and become a republican investor. It never really occured to me that the guy needed help. I always just figured that he liked living in a garbage can and liked being grumpy. Can you really change a monster if he doesn't want to be changed? You can take Oscar out of the garbage, but can you take the garbage out of Oscar?
Beginning this spring, Sesame Street will debut a new puppet named 'Noah,' who is intended to appeal to the show's burgeoning audience of young Christians. The character, whose puppet persona comes complete with an arc, will have responsibility for two letters in the alphabet call-out portion of the show: 'F,' which stands for 'flood,' and 'G,' which now stands for 'God.'
I get that the values I learned from the show are "Christian" values, but I also like to think that they are "Jewish" and "Muslim" and good "human" values. Why do all of these good values have to have a religion attached to them? Why can't the show just go on teaching counting, phonetics, friendship, and sharing without proselytizing to children? If parents want their kids learning about religion from the television, we have at least two stations here in Madison that they can tune into at any time of day or night for a good dose of God.
I understand that Sesame Street is changing. I understand that the show needs to tackle new topics, with a new look. (If they were still showing those skits from the early 80s, the show would just be a joke, just based on the clothing alone.) It seems to me, though, that the show is contributing to the idea that the media is responsible for the actions of our childeren. I
know that television shapes our ideas and has a huge impact on children. But if Bert and Ernie raise controversy because your five year old wants to know if they are "gay," well, why don't you talk to them about it? Maybe instead of blaming cookie monster for your kid's obesity, you should teach your kid about healthy habits. I understand the conundrum of the working family, that there is little time to sit down together and actually talk. But like those annoying PSAs, if you're not talking to your kids, who is?
Sesame Street teaches us that there might be monsters under our beds, but that they are friendly and just want to teach us how to count and spell. I'm not sure that Jim Henson would have wanted Sesame Street turning into a vehicle for the Christian right to spread a message of the intolerance of gays and the "homeless." I am proud to be part of the first generation to love Sesame Street, and while I still look forward to singing those songs with my kids someday, I'm sad that the message will be different.
This post has been brought to you by the letters "L" and "R," and the number "24."